Dijan explores why more analysis may not bring clarity, and how stable attention and embodied awareness can inform decisions alongside practical judgement.
Several years ago, I received an excellent job offer at a moment when I was facing a significant decision. I could return to Thailand and continue pursuing a path that had become deeply meaningful to me, or accept a position in the very city where, at that time, I imagined myself living.
Everything about the offer made sense. The work was something I knew I could excel at. The people were wonderful, and I felt an immediate connection with them. We had even attended the same high school, which gave the opportunity an unexpected sense of familiarity. They had tremendous confidence in me, and I was genuinely excited about what we were discussing.
Yet something extraordinary happened during that telephone conversation. As my excitement grew, I began having an asthma attack.
I was enthusiastic about the opportunity, but my body was responding in a completely different way. The contrast was so striking that I couldn't ignore it. I was considering a choice that appeared entirely reasonable, while something in me seemed deeply disturbed by the possibility of abandoning the direction I had already begun to follow.
I didn't yet have the understanding of attention and embodied awareness that I have today. But that experience stayed with me because it raised a question I would encounter repeatedly in my work: What happens when our reasoning gives us a convincing answer, yet we still don't feel clear about the decision?
When thinking has done its job but keeps going anyway
Thinking is an extraordinary faculty. It helps us organise information, compare possibilities, anticipate consequences and make practical judgements. When we face an important decision, careful analysis is often indispensable.
The difficulty begins when we continue analysing after the available information has already been considered.
We revisit the same arguments, imagine slightly different outcomes and search for one more piece of information that might finally settle the matter. Each round of thinking feels productive because we are actively engaging with the problem. Yet the underlying uncertainty remains.
I encounter this frequently in my work with capable, analytically strong women. They may understand their circumstances in considerable detail. They can explain the advantages and disadvantages of every option, recognise the practical consequences and anticipate how other people might respond. Nevertheless, when it comes to making the decision, they remain caught between possibilities.
Sometimes the problem is genuinely insufficient information. Sometimes a decision involves competing responsibilities or risks that deserve careful consideration. But there are also situations in which thinking has already provided everything it reasonably can, and the person is still waiting for analysis to produce a kind of certainty that analysis alone cannot provide.
At that point, the question is no longer simply what else needs to be considered. It is whether we can recognise what matters to us within everything we have considered.
The difference between analysis and clarity
When I received that job offer, I could have made an excellent argument for accepting it. The position suited my abilities, the people inspired confidence, and the location matched the life I had imagined for myself.
What those considerations couldn't fully answer was whether this was the life I wanted to choose.
There is a difference between understanding the available options and recognising your own direction within them. Analysis helps us establish what is possible, advantageous or sensible. Clarity also requires us to discern which considerations carry genuine significance for us, rather than treating every thought, expectation and anticipated consequence as equally important.
This is where attention becomes essential.
I use the term stable attention to describe the capacity to remain with a question or experience without immediately being carried away by the thoughts it generates. Instead of moving from one consequence to another, we develop the ability to observe what is happening within us while the question remains present.
This doesn't require suppressing thought or emptying the mind. It means being able to notice a thought without automatically following it into another round of analysis. We can recognise our fears, expectations, preferences and bodily responses without immediately trying to explain them away or turn them into a conclusion.
When attention becomes more stable, we have a better opportunity to distinguish the decision itself from the mental activity surrounding it.
We may discover that an option looks attractive primarily because it meets someone else's expectations. We may recognise that a particular fear has been dominating our thinking, even though it tells us little about what we actually want. Or we may notice a preference that has been present all along but has received very little attention because it doesn't fit neatly into our rational argument.
Clarity can emerge through this kind of recognition. It is not necessarily the arrival of new information, but a change in our ability to perceive and understand what is already there.
The body has something to contribute
My asthma attack during that telephone conversation was the strongest physical response I had ever experienced in relation to a decision.
I had always relied on intuition alongside logical reasoning. Even at school, when solving chemistry or mathematics problems, I often found that approaching a problem from an unexpected direction helped me arrive at solutions that systematic reasoning alone hadn't immediately revealed. The experience of knowing something without being able to explain every step of how I had arrived there was not unfamiliar to me.
But this was different. My body was reacting so intensely that I could no longer regard the decision as a purely intellectual exercise.
Today, I can place that experience within a broader understanding of embodied decision-making. Research into somatic markers explores how bodily and emotional signals may participate in evaluating choices, sometimes before we can consciously articulate the considerations involved.
That doesn't mean every bodily reaction is an accurate judgement about what we should do. Physical symptoms can have many causes, and anxiety, excitement, previous experiences and medical conditions can all influence what we feel. An asthma attack, in particular, is a medical event that requires appropriate care, not a decision-making instrument.
What mattered in my experience was that the physical response interrupted the apparent certainty of my reasoning. It made me pay attention to something I had not adequately acknowledged: accepting an excellent opportunity would also mean stepping away from a direction that mattered deeply to me.
I didn't take the job.
Looking back, I don't understand that decision as my body defeating my mind. I understand it as a moment when I could no longer ignore the difference between what looked right and what I recognised as right for me.
Learning to use more than one kind of intelligence
A woman I worked with, a lawyer from London, described herself as someone who obsessively overthought situations. She was accustomed to intellectualising her experiences, arguing with her emotions and trying to resolve uncertainty through further reasoning.
After our work together, she described an important shift:
"Dijan has taught me to think less with my head and to feel more with my heart."
What I find significant in her observation is not that she stopped thinking. Her analytical abilities remained valuable. What changed was her relationship with them.
She began allowing other aspects of her experience to inform her understanding rather than expecting intellectual analysis to carry the entire responsibility for every decision.
For people who have spent years developing their ability to think, plan, solve problems and anticipate difficulties, this can be unfamiliar territory. Their analytical intelligence has often contributed substantially to their success. It makes sense that they would rely on it when something important is at stake.
But the capacities that help us succeed at complex tasks don't necessarily give us immediate access to our own wishes, values or sense of direction.
We can become exceptionally skilled at evaluating what we could do while remaining uncertain about what we want to do.
Learning to recognise that distinction requires a different relationship with attention.
What to do when you keep going back and forth
If you have been returning to the same decision for weeks or months, it may be worth examining what actually happens each time you revisit it.
Are you discovering something new, or rehearsing arguments you already know? Is there a practical uncertainty that still needs to be resolved? Are you trying to find an option without disadvantages, or waiting for a guarantee that you won't regret your choice?
These distinctions matter because not every difficult decision calls for the same response.
Where information is missing, gather it. Where consequences need careful consideration, give them that consideration. But when you find yourself repeatedly circulating through familiar arguments, another round of analysis may simply reinforce the habit of searching for certainty through thought.
You can begin exploring a different approach by allowing the question to remain present without immediately trying to answer it.
Notice what happens when you consider each possibility. Pay attention to the thoughts that arise, but also to your emotional responses, bodily sensations and the assumptions that accompany them. Rather than treating any single reaction as an instruction, become curious about what it might reveal.
You may notice, for example, that much of your hesitation concerns disappointing someone else. Or that you have been giving disproportionate attention to a relatively minor risk because it is easier to analyse than the larger question of what you want. You may also discover that your uncertainty is meaningful and that the decision genuinely needs more time.
The purpose is not to force an intuitive answer or to make the body responsible for choosing. It is to become sufficiently attentive that you can recognise the different influences operating within you and consider them with greater discernment.
This is a capacity that develops through practice. As attention becomes more stable, we become less compelled to follow every thought and more able to remain present with an experience long enough to understand it.
Clarity doesn't always make a decision easy. You may still choose something difficult, accept uncertainty or face consequences you would rather avoid. But you can begin to recognise the difference between being unable to decide and being unwilling to stop thinking about the decision.
And sometimes that recognition is precisely what allows you to move.
Frequently asked questions
What is stable attention?
Stable attention is the capacity to remain aware of a question, thought or experience without immediately becoming absorbed in the reactions it produces. It allows you to observe your thinking, emotions and bodily responses with greater continuity, making it easier to recognise what is relevant rather than being pulled from one concern to another.
Why do I keep going back and forth on the same decision?
There are several possible reasons. You may need more information, be facing genuinely competing priorities or feel uncertain about the consequences. But when you repeatedly revisit the same considerations without discovering anything new, further analysis may no longer be helping. Developing the ability to observe your thoughts and reactions can help you understand what is keeping the decision unresolved.
Can I trust my body's response when making decisions?
Bodily responses can provide useful information about how you are experiencing a situation, but they are not infallible instructions. Stress, excitement, fear, health conditions and previous experiences can all influence them. The aim is to learn how to interpret these signals alongside practical information and conscious reasoning, rather than automatically obeying or dismissing them.
How can I develop stable attention?
Stable attention develops through practices that strengthen your capacity to observe experience without immediately reacting to it. These may include meditation, embodied awareness and guided inquiry into your habitual responses. In individual work, we can explore how you personally approach decisions, what happens to your attention under pressure and how to develop greater discernment.

